Phone: 317-286-3727





Business Hours

Sunday          11am - 4pm

Monday          CLOSED

Tuesday         10am - 5pm

Thursday     12pm - 7pm

Friday          10am - 5pm

Saturday      10am - 5pm

Wednesday    10am - 5pm


Standard Shipping Time: Most orders ship within 3 business days.


Create Your Own Pacifier sets require additional production time due to the custom nature of the product. Custom orders ship in 5-7 business days.


All returns accepted within 30 days of purchase date.


In the rare event of defective merchandise, Bottles 'N Binkies will reimburse customer for any return shipping costs incurred.


If you have any questions regarding a return please contact us


Please send returns, including original order number or packing slip to:


Returns Processing

1060 E. Main Street, Suite 100

Brownsburg, IN 46112